Time doesn't exist yet it controls us anyway
Continuing my trip up Empire's top 20 films of 2025
#2 : One Battle After Another
Paul Thomas Anderson has mastered so many genres and tones over the years, you’d think he’d done it all. And yet, in comes One Battle After Another, an entirely singular cinematic experience – part kidnap thriller, part revolutionary drama, part shambling shaggy-dog comedy – in the form of a dad-and-daughter love-letter. Leonardo DiCaprio is hilariously addled as Bob, the former revolutionary who’s been raising his daughter Willa (Chase Infiniti) and numbing his brain ever since his activist group went down. But when the past resurfaces, he has to dredge up his former life to chase Willa down, while pursued by Sean Penn’s bone-chilling Colonel Steven J. Lockjaw. Like the best of PTA’s work, there’s a pace and energy to One Battle that sees its significant runtime fly by – perfectly calibrated to make every gag, every emotional beat, every gut-punch land just right. This is revolutionary cinema, delivered with no fear. Just like Tom Cruise.
Paul Thomas Anderson is a curious one - you can feel the quality in his work, but I (for one) can't always feel the emotion. I don't particularly like Licorice Pizza. There Will Be Blood or The Master, but I've got a lot more time for Punch Drunk Love, Phantom Thread and Boogie Nights than I was expecting to - and that's pretty much the only theme those films have in common. So I've got no real idea what I'm going to get here or whether I'm going to like it...
Hmmm. Well.
I'm not going to give you any more details of the plot because you're best off not knowing but it is, as Empire says, "part shambling shaggy-dog comedy" so it's hard to take it too seriously. However, there are also other times when it's making very serious points (particularly within the context of the US currently) and then there are other times when it's all very tense - so it's hard to know exactly what to make of it.
However, for a film that's ten minutes short of three hours, I have to say it's remarkably engaging. For example, it has a most bizarre car chase in it (through some most amazing countryside) which goes on for ten minutes or so in which remarkably little happens, but it still manages to be surprisingly tense - I've no idea how he does it, so he's obviously good at what he does. I would say the last ten minutes or so feels a bit tacked on to satisfy test audiences who complained they didn't like the original ending, but it could be that PTA just felt the need to tie things up with a bow (but it's not something he generally cares too much about).
To no-one's surprise, there's some proper actors in this - and we obviously have to start with Leo as Bob. I always think I don't like him and so I instinctly avoid his films - but then when I see them, I generally quite enjoy both the film and his performance. And that's true here as well - he's very good, although it's worth pointing out that although he is one of the central characters, this is definitely not the hero role. He's washed-up, addicted and paranoid - and when he's forced to step up to the plate, he often fails miserably. But he acts at failing miserably very well indeed.
Next up - Sean Penn, who is b-b-bad to the bone as Colonel Stephen J. Lockjaw (which is never going to be used as the name for a good guy). Sean is most definitely an "interesting" character (his Wikipedia entry is fascinating) but I tend to admire his acting (he's amazingly good in Milk) and he certainly doesn't disappoint here even if the character is a bit "pantomime baddy".
So lets go from two reasonably high profile old white men (yes - Leo is old, he's 52!) to a less white younger lady - Chase Infiniti, who plays Willa, Bob's daughter, and she's a much nicer character than everyone we've met so far. And Chase protrays her well, with a steely determination and a strong "not taking any shit" attitude despite being somewhat out of her depth - with good reason, and I'm talking about the character here, not the actor.
Taking considerably less shit from anyone is Teyana Taylor as Perfidia Beverley Hills (possibly not her real name) who is Willa's mother - she puts in an impressive performance but it's a very cold and detached role, so she's not so likeable. Interestingly, her Wikipedia tells us she's a talented lady - we've previously met her in a singing capacity, she choreographed Beyonce's Ring The Alarm video at the age of 15, she was declared Time's Woman of The Year for 2025 and, even more impressively, she's won a season of The Masked Singer!
And there's one more person I want to call out - Benicio del Toro as Sergio St Carlos, who we originally meets as Willa's karate sensei but he turns out to be somewhat more important than that. I really like him in everything I've seen him in but he often plays things somewhat left field so it's nice to see him here just knocking it out of the park in a straightforward manner.
There are a load of other people in this and I think it would have been easy for me to get confused so it's to everyone's credit that I didn't - I didn't necessarily know who every character was, but I didn't have any issues working out they fitted in so I guess that means they all did a good job.
And of course it's well shot - there are some extremely complex scenes with an awful lot of people involved and the camera on the move a lot, but you still don't feel like you get lost in terms of what's going on. And there are also some nicely done simpler scenes where he just lets the actors do their thing - I may not always love his stuff but there's no doubt he has a vision and the ability to carry it through. I would say it has a weird musical score though - there's an awful lot of plinky-plonk piano jazz which doesn't really fit with anything.
One thing I do have to say is that this is most amusingly not a film with white saviour complex - the white guys are either amusingly useless (and Bob is definitely their spiritual leader) or evil bastards (with Colonel Lockjaw trying to be the baddest, but he has strong competition), with the women and minorities generally being principled, organised, strong and capable. There's also been some complaints from those of the right of politics that it glorifies revolutionaries - but who cares what that lot thinks about?!?
This feels like a film that was very keen to win some Academy Awards and it obviously worked out for plenty of people with it winning six including Best Picture, Director and Supporting Actor (for Sean, beating Benicio) - Leo lost out to a role we've yet to meet, which was similarly designed to attract Academy Award attention.
OK, OK - let's cut to the chase. Did I like it? Yes, I did, but I can't say I loved it and there's absolutely no danger of me ever watching it again - I'm sure I'd notice new things in terms of the performances if I did, but I know the story and don't feel there's a lot more to be gained there. But, all in all, it is a recommendation (I actually think you should always make an effort to watch the Best Picture winners) - and don't get put off by the running time because it's remarkably watchable all the way through. If you fancy it, then it's available to stream on Sky or to rent in all the usual places - so check it out.
Only one to go...
#3 - A very decent film

Comments
Post a Comment