The distance between what is said and what is known to be true has become an abyss.
Completing my trip up Empire's top 20 TV shows of 2025
#1 : Andor
“The distance between what is said and what is known to be true has become an abyss. Of all the things at risk, the loss of an objective reality is perhaps the most dangerous.” Mon Mothma’s blistering speech to the Imperial senate wasn’t the first body blow delivered by Tony Gilroy’s astonishing second season of Andor (even then, a part of us was still bleeding in the rubble of Palmo Plaza), but boy did it hit hard. Gilroy hasn’t been coy about the real-world inspirations for his revolutionary series, but never have the lines between Star Wars and the real world felt so gossamer thin. A tale of rebellion, what we sacrifice (“EVERYTHING!”), and the fragility of tyrannical rule, Andor stands as something quite extraordinary: a political manifesto, a masterclass in subtle character work, a gripping political thriller and the most accomplished piece of storytelling Star Wars has ever produced. That it emerged as a prequel to a prequel, turning a forgettable cypher into one of the saga’s most compelling heroes, is nothing short of astonishing. Mon Mothma’s trauma groove; Syril’s tragic revelation (“Who are you?”); Lonny slumped on a bench; Kleya’s final act of mercy; Dedra, head in hands, screaming at her fate; the series gifted us so many perfect moments that it’s hard to single out just one (or two, or ten!) Each of those moments contributed to a series that not only made for an incredible season of television, but one that completely transformed the way all of us will see Lucas’ franchise going forwards.
I liked Season 1, but not as much as Empire did - so I checked out the second season at the time and I did enjoy it, but not as much as Empire did...
The first thing I have to say about it is that remember remarkably little about it. I do remember it had an ambitiously complex plot which didn't always make a whole lot of sense to me (which I suspected was down to unfamiliarity with the long grass of the lore, but never cared enough about to investigate). And the other thing I remember is, despite the complex plot, a load of episodes had amazingly little happen in them - the first six episodes in particular were incredibly slow paced. I do remember enjoying some of the second half though, but I'd struggle to name anyone that was in it beyond Diego Luna and Stellan Starsgard.
A quick trawl through Wikipedia reminds me that there are a LOT of people in this, plenty returning from season 1 but there are also new faces thrown in there to enable them to expand the story - everyone does a good job (now I've been reminded who was in it), but I'm gonna call out Genevieve O'Reilly as Mon Mothma, who has a lot to do here as she gets caught in much political machination.
The other main thing I remember taking away from this is how fabulous it looked at all times and they'd obviously thrown a shedload of money at it but, in true Star Wars fashion, it wasn't always clear that they'd obviously picked the right things to splash the cash on - there are interminable sumptuous banquet scenes that don't really do anything other than go "wow, look at how great we look". There was a great protest shoot-out scene though which looked fantastic - I'd have taken a few more of them across the season in preference to the pointless aliens and costumes that get everywhere.
I don't really feel the need to write any more on this - if you like Star Wars then you're already going to have watched this. Despite it being well done though, it certainly wasn't the best thing on telly last year - I'd be happy giving it a top ten place but it wouldn't be in my top five, I'm afraid. But Empire are always gonna nuts on anything Star Wars (they gave Attack Of The Clones five stars at the time!) so we are where we are. However, I do have to admit it's one of the best entries in their TV catalogue (it has some actual plot, for starters) and the two seasons stand alone reasonably well, so if you're looking to scratch a sci-fi itch and you've not been here then you might like to consider it.
And with that, we're finished with Empire's lists for the year (except for the obligatory summary post, of course).
#2 - Some impressive telly

Comments
Post a Comment